Ithaca, NY, a vibrant college town nestled in the Finger Lakes region, boasts a surprisingly diverse and delicious wing scene. Forget just "good" – we're talking legendary, mouthwatering, finger-licking good buffalo wings. This guide dives deep into the top 16 spots to satisfy your wing cravings, covering everything from classic styles to innovative twists. Whether you prefer bone-in, boneless, or a unique sauce, this list has something for every wing aficionado. This isn't just a list; it's a journey through Ithaca's best wing establishments.
Classic Ithaca Wing Joints: Tried and True
These establishments have stood the test of time, earning their reputations through consistently delicious wings and loyal customer bases.
1. The Nines: A Collegetown Classic
The Nines, a Collegetown staple, is known for its massive portions and classic buffalo wing preparation. They nail the balance of crispy skin and juicy meat. Their sauce is a perfect blend of tangy and spicy, making it a go-to for students and locals alike. Many consider their "suicide" wings a rite of passage for Ithaca newcomers.
2. Hector's: A Local Favorite
Hector's offers a consistently excellent wing experience. Their secret? Fresh, high-quality ingredients and a commitment to classic buffalo wing flavors. They offer a range of heat levels, ensuring everyone finds their perfect spice match. Their slightly thicker sauce clings nicely to the wings, enhancing the flavor.
3. Collegetown Bagels: More Than Just Bagels
While famous for their bagels, Collegetown Bagels also serves up some seriously impressive wings. Their wings are perfectly crispy, and their sauces range from mild to scorching hot. The convenience of grabbing wings and bagels in one location is a huge plus for busy students.
4. The Ithaca Beer Company: Wings & Brews
Pair your perfect wing with the perfect brew at the Ithaca Beer Company. Their wings are a solid choice, complementing their extensive beer selection. The casual atmosphere makes it a great spot for a relaxed evening out. They often have seasonal wing specials worth checking out!
Beyond the Basics: Unique Wing Experiences
Ithaca's wing scene extends beyond the traditional, with restaurants offering creative spins on this beloved dish.
5. Maxie's: Gourmet Wings with a Twist
Maxie's elevates the wing game with gourmet options. Expect unique sauces and flavor combinations you won't find anywhere else. Think chipotle-lime, Korean BBQ, or even a sweet and spicy mango habanero. Their commitment to quality ingredients shines through.
6. State Street Eats: Diverse Menu, Delicious Wings
State Street Eats offers a broad menu with a dedicated wing section. Their wings are known for their consistent crispiness and a good variety of sauces. They often offer daily specials, making it worthwhile to check their menu frequently.
7. Epiphany: Upscale Dining with Wing Options
For a more refined wing experience, head to Epiphany. Their wings may not be the focus of their menu, but they’re still high-quality and prepared with the same attention to detail as their other dishes.
Hidden Gems: Ithaca's Undiscovered Wing Wonders
These spots may be less publicized, but they offer excellent wings that deserve recognition.
8. Rongovian Embassy: A Quirky Spot with Great Wings
Rongovian Embassy, known for its quirky atmosphere, also serves some excellent wings. It's a hidden gem that often gets overlooked, but their delicious wings and fun environment are worth the visit.
9. Levelz: A Late-Night Wing Haven
Perfect for those late-night cravings, Levelz offers a solid selection of wings. Their hours make them convenient for those looking for a post-bar snack.
10. Za! Pizzeria: Wings Complementing the Pizza
Za! is primarily known for their pizza but their wings are equally delicious and a great complement to a pizza order. A classic combination that makes for a satisfying meal.
Beyond Buffalo: Exploring Wing Variations
Some Ithaca establishments offer wings with more than just the classic buffalo sauce. Let's explore those!
11. Glazed & Confused: Sweet & Savory Wings
Glazed & Confused focuses on sweet and savory wing combinations. They may not be strictly Buffalo wings, but the flavour profiles are exciting and worth checking out!
12. Local Bar (Name Varies): Check your local bar options!
Many local bars across Ithaca offer their own versions of wings, often with interesting and unique sauces. It's worth exploring your neighborhood bars to uncover their hidden wing treasures!
Quick Bites and Casual Options
These spots are perfect for a quick and satisfying wing fix.
13. Wegmans: A Grocery Store Surprise
Even Wegmans, the popular grocery store, serves decent wings that are surprisingly good for their convenience and affordability. A great option for a quick and easy meal.
Exploring Unique Wing Styles
Let's move beyond the classic buffalo wing and examine some other varieties offered around Ithaca.
14. Boneless Wings Options: Many Restaurants Offer Them
Many of the restaurants listed above also offer boneless wings for those who prefer a different texture or ease of eating.
15. Dry Rub Wings: A Flavorful Alternative
Some restaurants will offer dry rub wings, focusing on spices and herbs instead of a saucy coating.
The Verdict: Your Ithaca Wing Quest
This comprehensive guide covers a wide range of Ithaca’s best wing options. From classic buffalo wings to unique flavor combinations, there’s something for every palate. Remember to check restaurant websites for hours, menus, and any daily specials. Your Ithaca wing quest awaits!
16. Your Favorite Local Spot: Discover Your Own Gem!
Finally, don't forget to explore! Ithaca's culinary scene is dynamic, and new wing havens might be just around the corner. Share your discoveries in the comments below. What are your go-to spots for wings in Ithaca?
