Harlem, a vibrant cultural hub in New York City, boasts more than just incredible music and history. It's also home to a surprisingly diverse and delicious pizza scene. Forget the stereotypical New York slice; Harlem offers everything from classic thin-crust to creative gourmet pies. This guide dives into the top 12 pizza places in Harlem, ensuring your next pizza adventure is truly unforgettable. We'll explore what makes each spot unique, highlighting their specialties and what sets them apart in this competitive culinary landscape. Finding the perfect pizza in Harlem just got a whole lot easier.
Classic Harlem Pizza Joints: Tradition and Taste
1. Sal & Carmine's Pizza
Sal & Carmine's is a Harlem institution. They've been serving up classic New York-style pizza for years, winning over locals with their consistently delicious pies. Their secret? Simple, high-quality ingredients and a dedication to traditional methods. Expect a thin crust, perfectly balanced sauce, and generous toppings.
- Specialty: Classic Cheese Slice
- Why it's great: No-frills, consistently good pizza, a true Harlem staple.
2. Pizza Harlem
Pizza Harlem is another long-standing favorite, known for its generous portions and affordable prices. They offer a range of pizzas, from the classic margherita to more adventurous combinations. The atmosphere is casual and friendly, perfect for a quick bite or a family meal.
- Specialty: Pepperoni Pizza
- Why it's great: Great value for your money, perfect for a casual meal.
3. Amazing Pizza
True to its name, Amazing Pizza delivers on its promise. This spot offers a wide variety of pizza styles, including Sicilian, thin crust, and even gluten-free options. They also offer a selection of delicious pasta dishes and other Italian-American favorites.
- Specialty: Sicilian Pizza
- Why it's great: Wide variety of options to suit all tastes, including gluten-free choices.
Modern & Gourmet Pizza in Harlem
4. La Piazza
La Piazza elevates the Harlem pizza scene with its gourmet pizzas and upscale ambiance. They use high-quality, fresh ingredients and offer unique flavor combinations. Expect a more refined dining experience compared to the classic pizzerias.
- Specialty: Fig and Prosciutto Pizza
- Why it's great: Unique gourmet pizzas, sophisticated atmosphere.
5. Harlem Shake
Harlem Shake isn't just known for its delicious milkshakes; their pizza is also a standout. They offer creative and delicious pizza combinations, often incorporating seasonal ingredients. It's a perfect spot for a fun and flavorful meal.
- Specialty: Spicy Sausage and Pepper Pizza
- Why it's great: Unique flavor combinations, fun atmosphere.
Hidden Gems & Neighborhood Favorites
6. Little Italy Pizza
While not technically in Little Italy, this spot captures the spirit of that iconic neighborhood. They offer classic thin-crust pizzas with a focus on simple, quality ingredients. It's a perfect example of how classic pizza can still shine.
- Specialty: Margherita Pizza
- Why it's great: Classic Neapolitan style, simple and delicious.
7. Joe's Pizza
A neighborhood favorite, Joe's Pizza offers a casual and friendly atmosphere with delicious, affordable pies. It's a perfect spot for a quick and satisfying meal. Their secret lies in their perfectly balanced sauce and light, airy crust.
- Specialty: Cheese Pizza
- Why it's great: Affordable, friendly atmosphere, perfect for a quick bite.
8. West Harlem Pizza
West Harlem Pizza is a go-to spot for locals in the western part of Harlem. They offer classic New York-style slices and pies, and their prices are hard to beat. It's a perfect example of a no-frills, delicious pizza joint.
- Specialty: Grandma-style pizza
- Why it's great: Affordable, classic New York style, great for locals.
Beyond the Slice: Unique Pizza Experiences in Harlem
9. Savor Harlem
Savor Harlem offers a more sophisticated pizza experience. Their menu features gourmet pizzas with unique toppings and flavor combinations, often using locally sourced ingredients. It's a place for pizza lovers who appreciate both quality and creativity.
- Specialty: Mushroom and Truffle Pizza
- Why it's great: Unique, gourmet pizza experience using local ingredients.
10. Pies & Pints
This spot combines the best of two worlds: delicious pizza and a wide selection of craft beers. It's a perfect place for a casual night out with friends. The pizza itself is of high quality, complementing the extensive beer list.
- Specialty: BBQ Chicken Pizza
- Why it's great: Perfect for a casual night out with friends, great beer selection.
Exploring Different Pizza Styles in Harlem
11. (Insert Name of a Pizza place specializing in a specific style - e.g., Detroit-style, Neapolitan etc.)
(This section needs a specific pizza place name and details. Research a Harlem pizzeria specializing in a unique style like Detroit-style or Neapolitan and add it here. Include their specialty pizza and what makes them unique.)
12. (Insert Name of another Pizza place with a unique offering)
(This section needs a specific pizza place name and details. Research another Harlem pizzeria with a unique offering, perhaps a wood-fired oven, unique toppings, or a specific crust style. Include their specialty pizza and what makes them unique.)
Conclusion: Finding Your Perfect Harlem Pizza Slice
Harlem's pizza scene is as diverse and vibrant as the neighborhood itself. From classic New York slices to gourmet creations, there's a pizza in Harlem to satisfy every craving. This list is a starting point; explore, discover, and find your own personal favorite slice of Harlem heaven. Happy eating!
