Brooklyn Heights boasts stunning views of the Manhattan skyline, and its culinary scene is just as captivating. While diverse in its offerings, the neighborhood has a surprising number of excellent seafood restaurants. This guide highlights six of the best, ensuring your next seafood dining experience in Brooklyn Heights is unforgettable. We'll explore their menus, ambiance, and what makes each one special, helping you choose the perfect spot for your taste and budget.
A Deep Dive into Brooklyn Heights' Seafood Scene
Finding the perfect seafood restaurant can feel like searching for a needle in a haystack, especially in a vibrant city like New York. Brooklyn Heights, with its blend of upscale establishments and cozy neighborhood gems, offers a fantastic variety. This list considers several factors, including freshness of ingredients, quality of preparation, ambiance, service, and price point. We’ve tasted, reviewed, and researched to bring you this curated selection.
1. The River Café: Iconic Views and Upscale Seafood
The River Café is a Brooklyn Heights institution. Perched on the waterfront with breathtaking views of the Manhattan skyline, it’s renowned for its elegant ambiance and refined seafood dishes. Expect expertly prepared dishes using seasonal, locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Their wine list is extensive and perfectly complements the menu.
Why it's great:
- Unparalleled views: The panoramic views of the Manhattan skyline are a major draw.
- High-quality ingredients: The River Café is known for its commitment to fresh, seasonal ingredients.
- Elegant ambiance: Perfect for special occasions or a romantic dinner.
- Extensive wine list: A curated selection of wines to pair perfectly with your meal.
Price Point: $$
2. Juliana's Pizza: More Than Just Pizza (Yes, Seafood Too!)
While famous for its Neapolitan-style pizzas, Juliana's also offers a surprisingly delicious selection of seafood appetizers and entrees. Their clams casino is a local favorite, and their grilled octopus is tender and flavorful. While not strictly a seafood restaurant, it's worth including for its quality seafood options in a more casual setting.
Why it's great:
- Casual atmosphere: Relaxed and welcoming, perfect for a casual dinner or lunch.
- Excellent pizza: Even if you're not here solely for seafood, the pizza is worth trying.
- Great value: More affordable than some of the other options on this list.
- Convenient location: Situated in the heart of Brooklyn Heights.
Price Point: $
3. Cecconi's Dumbo: A Stylish Italian Option (with Seafood!)
Technically located in Dumbo, just a short walk from Brooklyn Heights, Cecconi’s offers a sophisticated Italian dining experience with excellent seafood options. Their menu features classic Italian dishes with a modern twist, featuring fresh seafood prepared with skill and artistry. The atmosphere is stylish and chic, making it ideal for a special occasion.
Why it's great:
- Stylish ambiance: Sophisticated and chic, ideal for a special occasion.
- Creative Italian dishes: Innovative takes on classic Italian seafood dishes.
- Excellent service: Attentive and professional staff.
- Close proximity to Brooklyn Heights: Easily accessible from Brooklyn Heights.
Price Point: $$
4. DeStefano's Steak House: A Seafood Surprise (among Steaks!)
While primarily a steakhouse, DeStefano's offers some surprisingly delicious seafood dishes. Their lobster mac and cheese is a decadent treat, and their grilled seafood platters are a hearty and satisfying option. It's a good choice for those who want a blend of steak and seafood options in a classic American steakhouse setting.
Why it's great:
- Unique combination: Steakhouse with surprisingly good seafood.
- Hearty portions: Perfect for those with a big appetite.
- Classic American ambiance: Traditional steakhouse atmosphere.
- Good for groups: Plenty of space for larger groups.
Price Point: $$
5. Grimaldi's Pizzeria: Another Pizza Place with Seafood Delights
Similar to Juliana's, Grimaldi's is another Brooklyn Heights institution known primarily for its pizza. However, they do offer a small but well-executed selection of seafood appetizers, making it a convenient option for a quick and tasty seafood snack. Their clam appetizer is particularly noteworthy.
Why it's great:
- Iconic location: Under the Brooklyn Bridge, a classic Brooklyn experience.
- Great for a quick bite: Perfect for a casual lunch or appetizer.
- Affordable: More budget-friendly than many other seafood options.
- Popular spot: Expect a potential wait during peak hours.
Price Point: $
6. Luke's Lobster: Fast, Fresh, and Fantastic
Luke's Lobster offers a quick and delicious seafood experience, perfect for a casual lunch or takeaway. They're known for their fresh lobster rolls and other seafood offerings, made with high-quality ingredients. It's a perfect choice for a simple, satisfying, and reasonably priced seafood meal.
Why it's great:
- Fast and convenient: Perfect for a quick lunch or takeaway.
- High-quality ingredients: Fresh and flavorful seafood.
- Affordable: More budget-friendly than fine-dining restaurants.
- Multiple locations: Easy to find, with various locations throughout NYC.
Price Point: $
Conclusion: Finding Your Perfect Brooklyn Heights Seafood Spot
Brooklyn Heights offers a fantastic range of seafood dining options, catering to various tastes and budgets. Whether you're seeking a romantic dinner with stunning views, a casual meal with friends, or a quick and tasty lunch, this guide provides a starting point for your culinary adventures. Remember to check restaurant websites for menus, hours, and reservations, especially for the more popular establishments. Enjoy your delicious seafood experience in beautiful Brooklyn Heights!
