Sheepshead Bay, a vibrant Brooklyn neighborhood nestled on the shores of Jamaica Bay, is renowned for its fresh seafood. Among its many culinary treasures, calamari reigns supreme. This isn't just any calamari; we're talking about expertly fried, tender, and flavorful calamari, a testament to the area's rich Italian-American heritage. This guide dives deep into the best nine spots to experience the ultimate Sheepshead Bay calamari. We'll explore what makes each location unique, highlighting their special preparations and overall dining experience. Get ready to embark on a calamari adventure!
Top 9 Calamari Destinations in Sheepshead Bay
Finding the perfect calamari can be a culinary quest, but fear not! We've done the hard work for you, sampling the best Sheepshead Bay has to offer. This list isn't ranked, as each restaurant provides a unique and delicious experience.
1. L&B Spumoni Gardens
Known for its iconic Sicilian-style pizza, L&B Spumoni Gardens also serves up some seriously good calamari. Their recipe features perfectly crisp rings, a light and airy batter, and a generous helping of marinara sauce. The freshness of the seafood is undeniable.
- What makes it special: The classic preparation highlights the quality of the calamari itself. The portion size is generous, making it perfect for sharing.
- Atmosphere: Lively, family-friendly, a classic Sheepshead Bay experience.
2. Gargiulo's Restaurant
A Sheepshead Bay institution, Gargiulo's offers stunning waterfront views alongside its delicious menu. Their calamari is a standout, showcasing fresh, local ingredients. They often offer variations beyond the classic fried rings, such as grilled or stuffed calamari.
- What makes it special: The beautiful setting enhances the dining experience. The menu variations offer diverse calamari options for adventurous eaters.
- Atmosphere: Upscale, romantic, perfect for a special occasion.
3. Island Fish Co.
Island Fish Co. emphasizes its commitment to sourcing sustainable seafood. Their calamari reflects this dedication, with tender, flavorful rings that are expertly fried. The simple preparation allows the quality of the seafood to truly shine.
- What makes it special: Focus on sustainable seafood; a lighter, crispier batter than other spots.
- Atmosphere: Casual, friendly, ideal for a quick and tasty meal.
4. The Clam Bar
True to its name, The Clam Bar specializes in shellfish, and their calamari lives up to expectations. Their preparation boasts a flavorful, crispy batter, and their fresh-made marinara is the perfect accompaniment.
- What makes it special: Exceptional marinara sauce, perfectly complements the calamari.
- Atmosphere: Classic seafood shack vibe, laid-back and casual.
5. Rollin' Dough Pizza & Pasta
While known for its pizzas and pasta, Rollin’ Dough serves an excellent calamari appetizer. The focus is on a crispy, flavorful fry, and the generous portion makes it ideal for sharing before the main course.
- What makes it special: A tasty and affordable option alongside their other menu items.
- Atmosphere: Casual, family-friendly, a good choice for a quick bite.
6. Rosario's Pizza & Pasta
Rosario's is a local favorite for delicious Italian-American fare. Their calamari is a popular appetizer, known for its consistently crispy texture and fresh taste.
- What makes it special: Consistently high quality and dependable.
- Atmosphere: Friendly, neighborhood spot, welcoming to both families and individuals.
7. Lenny's Clam Bar
Another Sheepshead Bay clam bar contender, Lenny's offers fresh, flavorful calamari, fried to perfection. Their friendly service and relaxed atmosphere make it a local favorite.
- What makes it special: Their classic preparation, done consistently well.
- Atmosphere: Casual, relaxed, perfect for a casual meal.
8. Marine Park Seafood Restaurant
Marine Park Seafood isn't located directly in Sheepshead Bay, but its close proximity and excellent calamari warrant inclusion. They offer a variety of calamari preparations, often including grilled options.
- What makes it special: Menu variety beyond typical fried calamari; good value.
- Atmosphere: Casual, family-friendly, good for groups.
9. Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana (While not strictly in Sheepshead Bay, it's worth mentioning)
While a bit further afield, Totonno's is a legendary Coney Island pizzeria worth considering for its incredible calamari, though they are more famous for pizza. The journey is worth it for those seeking a truly exceptional calamari experience.
- What makes it special: A legendary pizzeria's take on calamari, a unique culinary experience.
- Atmosphere: Historic, iconic, a slice of New York City history.
Choosing Your Calamari Adventure
This guide provides a starting point for your Sheepshead Bay calamari exploration. Each restaurant offers a slightly different experience, from casual eateries to upscale waterfront dining. Remember to check reviews and menus before heading out, and most importantly, enjoy your delicious culinary journey! The best calamari experience is subjective, so try a few and discover your personal favorite!
