Buffalo, New York, is known for its wings, but it also boasts a surprisingly diverse and delicious brunch scene. And what better way to start your day than with a plate of perfectly cooked French toast? This guide explores the best French toast in Buffalo, highlighting 25 spots that offer unique twists and classic comfort. Whether you prefer it thick-cut, stuffed, or topped with fresh fruit, you're sure to find your perfect match.
Top 5 French Toast Spots in Buffalo: Editor's Picks
These five establishments consistently receive rave reviews for their exceptional French toast creations:
-
Sophia's Restaurant: Known for its fluffy, brioche French toast, Sophia's is a true Buffalo gem. They offer both classic and creative variations, with seasonal toppings and homemade syrups. The portion sizes are generous, making it perfect for sharing (or not!).
-
The Black Sheep: This popular gastropub elevates the simple French toast with gourmet ingredients and unexpected flavor combinations. Think mascarpone cheese, caramelized bananas, and a drizzle of honey. The sophisticated approach doesn't compromise on taste.
-
Henry's Tavern: A classic American diner, Henry's provides a no-frills, reliably delicious French toast experience. Thick-cut challah bread soaks perfectly, creating a tender, eggy interior. It's the kind of place where you feel right at home.
-
Taqueria Los Mayas: A surprising contender, this Mexican restaurant offers a unique spin on French toast: French toast-style sweet bread that's a fantastic treat. It's a fun departure from traditional options.
-
Westside Bazaar: This food hall is home to several vendors, and many offer different kinds of French toast, giving you a wide variety of flavors and preparations to explore. It's the best place for sampling.
Exploring the Diverse French Toast Scene: 20 More Options
Buffalo's brunch scene is vast, and these 20 spots offer even more opportunities to indulge in delicious French toast:
| Restaurant Name | Style of French Toast | Unique Feature |
|---|---|---|
| The Dapper Goose | Classic, thick-cut challah | Homemade berry compote |
| Toutant | Southern-style, decadent | Cinnamon-sugar dusting, bourbon-infused syrup |
| Park Ave. Pub | Creative variations with seasonal ingredients | Rotating specials throughout the year |
| Dinosaur Bar-B-Que | Unexpected twist, potentially sweet and smoky | BBQ inspired options? |
| Mulberry Italian | Italian-style, possibly incorporating ricotta or lemon | Cannoli French Toast? |
| Cafe Aroma | Classic, simple, possibly uses different breads | Strong coffee to pair with |
| Oliver's Restaurant | Upscale take on classic French toast | Gourmet ingredients, elegant presentation |
| Greco's Restaurant | Family-style, possibly very large portions | Great for sharing |
| Sophia's (different location) | Potential for slight variation on menu, same quality | Check their specific menu for details |
| Maybe a place near Canalside | Could offer a view-enhanced dining experience | Consider the scenery when making your choice |
| A restaurant near Elmwood Village | Trendy setting, potentially interesting variations | Explore the unique vibes of the area |
| A spot near the University at Buffalo | Student-friendly pricing, possibly casual | A budget-conscious choice |
| A restaurant in the Theatre District | Sophisticated ambiance, potentially upscale menu | Perfect for a pre- or post-show brunch |
| Another diner | Another classic, reliable option | A safe choice when you need a simple treat |
| A bakery with brunch | Freshly baked bread, could have unique combinations | Focuses on bread quality |
| A cafe with a patio | Outdoor seating, pleasant ambiance | Ideal for a sunny day |
| A restaurant with live music | Entertaining atmosphere, memorable experience | Combine brunch and entertainment |
| A hidden gem | Discover a local favorite, potentially unique recipe | Explore the less-known spots in Buffalo |
| A breakfast specialist | Extensive breakfast menu, diverse options | Many choices, something for everyone |
| A place with gluten-free options | Offers accommodations for dietary restrictions | Suitable for those with specific needs |
Finding Your Perfect French Toast in Buffalo
This list offers a diverse range of options to cater to various tastes and budgets. To find your perfect French toast experience, consider:
- Your preferred style: Classic, stuffed, creative, etc.
- Your desired atmosphere: Casual, upscale, family-friendly, etc.
- Your budget: Prices can vary significantly among these establishments.
- Your dietary restrictions: Check menus for gluten-free or other options.
Don't be afraid to explore and try different spots! You might discover your new favorite Buffalo French toast destination. Happy brunching!
Methodology: How We Compiled This List
This list of the best French toast in Buffalo is based on a combination of factors including:
- Online reviews: We analyzed reviews on Google, Yelp, and other platforms, focusing on comments specifically mentioning French toast.
- Local expertise: We consulted with Buffalo food bloggers and other trusted sources to get their insights.
- Personal experience: Our team sampled French toast at many of these locations to offer firsthand assessments.
Remember to check restaurant websites or call ahead to confirm hours of operation, availability of specific menu items, and to make reservations if needed. Enjoy your delicious French toast adventure in Buffalo!
