Finding the perfect pizza slice in a city known for its pizza is no easy feat. But in Bedford-Stuyvesant, a neighborhood brimming with character and culture, the search for delicious pizza becomes an exciting culinary adventure. This guide dives deep into the best 15 pizza places in Bed-Stuy, offering a detailed look at what makes each one unique and worth a visit. Whether you crave classic New York-style, creative gourmet pies, or something in between, this list has something for every pizza lover.
Top 5 Must-Try Pizza Spots in Bed-Stuy
These pizza places consistently receive rave reviews and represent the pinnacle of Bed-Stuy's pizza scene. Their popularity speaks volumes about the quality and taste they deliver.
-
Paulie Gee's: Known for its creative and high-quality ingredients, Paulie Gee's isn't your average pizza joint. This spot offers a unique selection of gourmet pizzas, showcasing both classic and innovative combinations. Their Hellboy pizza, with its spicy soppressata and pepperoni, is a fan favorite. Expect to wait, especially on weekends, but the pizza is well worth it.
-
Pizza Moto: This popular pizzeria stands out with its wood-fired oven and Neapolitan-style pizzas. Pizza Moto offers a diverse menu, including vegetarian options, and its pizzas are characterized by their crispy crusts and flavorful toppings. Their margherita pizza is a must-try for purists, showcasing the freshness of the ingredients.
-
L&B Spumoni Gardens: While technically located just outside Bed-Stuy's core, this iconic Brooklyn institution is close enough to merit inclusion. Famous for their Sicilian-style pizza, L&B offers massive, thick-crust slices brimming with cheese and tomato sauce. It’s a classic for a reason. Be prepared for a potential wait and a sizable portion!
-
Emily: This trendy spot serves up some of the most Instagrammable pizzas in the city. Their creative pies, featuring unique toppings and flavorful combinations, are a delight for both the eyes and the palate. They also offer excellent cocktails. Emily is a bit more upscale than some other options on this list.
-
Roberta's Pizza: While slightly further afield, Roberta's remains a staple for many Bed-Stuy residents due to its reputation for high-quality, creative pizzas. Their wood-fired pies are known for their charred crust and carefully curated toppings. You can expect a bit of a wait at this popular pizza spot.
The Next 10: Great Pizza Options in Bedford-Stuyvesant
These places offer diverse styles and flavors, ensuring that everyone can find their perfect Bed-Stuy pizza experience.
-
Grimaldi's Pizzeria (DUMBO): While technically located in DUMBO, its proximity and popularity among Bed-Stuy residents warrant mention. It's renowned for its coal-fired pizzas and stunning views of the Manhattan skyline.
-
Juliana's Pizza (DUMBO): Another DUMBO gem, Juliana's offers a similar coal-fired experience to Grimaldi's, often sparking friendly debates over which is superior. The important thing is – they're both delicious!
-
Prince Street Pizza (NoLIta): While not in Bed-Stuy, its reputation precedes it, and it’s a common destination for pizza lovers across Brooklyn. They're known for their classic New York-style slices.
-
Joe's Pizza (Various Locations): A New York City institution, Joe's Pizza has multiple locations, and the closest one might be a convenient option for Bed-Stuy residents. Expect classic NY slices at a reasonable price.
-
Lombardi's Pizza (Little Italy): A historic pizzeria in Little Italy, Lombardi's is a bit of a trek, but for those seeking an authentic taste of history, it's an unforgettable experience.
-
Other Notable Mentions: Bed-Stuy's vibrant culinary scene is constantly evolving, so always be on the lookout for new pizza places popping up. Check local review sites and social media for hidden gems.
-
Your Neighborhood Slice Shop: Don't overlook the smaller, less-hyped pizza places near you. These can often provide excellent value and surprisingly delicious pies.
-
Delivery Options: Many national chains deliver to Bed-Stuy, but for the true Bed-Stuy pizza experience, we recommend prioritizing the local pizzerias.
-
Seasonal Specials: Many pizzerias offer seasonal specials featuring locally sourced ingredients, adding an exciting element to your pizza journey.
-
Consider Your Budget: Prices can vary considerably between these establishments, so it's essential to factor in your budget when making your choice.
Finding Your Perfect Bed-Stuy Pizza
The best pizza place in Bed-Stuy is ultimately a matter of personal preference. This guide offers a diverse range of options to suit every taste and budget. Don't hesitate to explore and discover your own favorite hidden gem amidst the neighborhood's thriving pizza scene! Remember to check hours of operation and consider making reservations, especially for popular spots. Happy pizza hunting!
