Williamsburg, Brooklyn, a haven of hipsters, art, and incredible food, boasts a pizza scene as diverse and vibrant as its population. Forget the usual suspects; this isn't your average pizza guide. We've scoured the borough to bring you the best pizza in Williamsburg, offering a diverse range of styles, from classic New York slices to innovative, gourmet pies. Prepare for a delicious journey through 14 of the best pizza places Williamsburg has to offer! This guide will help you find the perfect pizza experience, whether you're craving a quick slice or a leisurely pizza night out.
Finding Your Perfect Williamsburg Pizza Slice: A Guide to Styles
Before we dive into the top 14, let's explore the pizza landscape of Williamsburg. The neighborhood caters to a wide range of tastes, meaning you'll find everything from classic New York-style thin crust to Neapolitan-style pizzas with puffy, airy crusts.
Understanding the Styles:
- New York Style: Thin crust, large slices, often with a slightly foldable, crispy edge. Think classic cheese or pepperoni.
- Neapolitan Style: A slightly charred, puffy crust with a soft interior, typically smaller in size than New York-style pizzas. Often features high-quality ingredients and creative toppings.
- Detroit Style: A deep-dish pizza baked in a rectangular pan, with a crispy, caramelized crust.
- Sicilian Style: A thick, rectangular pizza with a slightly spongy crust.
This variety ensures there’s a perfect pizza for everyone in Williamsburg. Now, let's get to the list!
Top 14 Pizza Places in Williamsburg: A Delicious Ranking
This list isn't ranked strictly from "best" to "worst" because taste is subjective! Instead, it's categorized to highlight the unique offerings of each pizzeria. Consider your personal preferences and choose your adventure!
Classic New York Style:
-
Joe's Pizza: A Williamsburg institution, Joe's is known for its massive, foldable slices of classic New York pizza. It's a true testament to the simple perfection of a well-made cheese slice. Expect a line, especially on weekends!
-
Grimaldi's Pizzeria (DUMBO - Close Enough!): While technically in DUMBO, it's a short walk across the bridge and a must-mention for its coal-fired, classic New York pies. The slightly charred crust is simply divine.
-
Lombardi's Pizza (Little Italy - Another Close Contender!): Another slightly further-a-field recommendation, Lombardi's is the original New York pizza, holding a historical significance. It's a little bit of a journey but worth it for its classic charm and excellent pies.
Neapolitan & Gourmet Pizzas:
-
Lilia: This Michelin-starred restaurant offers incredibly high-quality Neapolitan pizzas with seasonal ingredients. Be prepared for a higher price point, but the experience is worth it.
-
Paulie Gee's: Known for its creative and gourmet pizzas with unique topping combinations. Paulie Gee's pushes the boundaries of traditional pizza-making.
-
Roberta's Pizza: A Williamsburg staple, Roberta's is famous for its wood-fired pizzas and lively atmosphere. It’s a great place to enjoy a casual pizza night with friends.
Unique & Creative Pizza Experiences:
-
Emmy Squared: Offers a Detroit-style pizza with a unique, crispy crust and a variety of interesting toppings.
-
Pizza Moto: A fun, casual spot with creative pizzas and a great atmosphere. A solid choice for a unique pizza experience.
Casual & Quick Bites:
-
Pizza Village: A great option for a quick and delicious slice of pizza. Perfect for a casual lunch or a late-night snack.
-
Best Pizza: Simple, classic slices, perfect for those looking for an affordable and satisfying meal. Don't let the name fool you – this place delivers!
-
Juliana's Pizza (DUMBO - Another Close One!): Sister restaurant to Grimaldi's, Juliana's offers a similar coal-fired pizza experience with a slightly different feel.
Hidden Gems & Neighborhood Favorites:
-
Motorino: While known for their multiple locations, the Williamsburg outpost is a must-visit for its upscale Neapolitan pizzas.
-
Via Carota: While primarily an Italian restaurant, their pizzas are a highlight, made with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
-
Your Neighborhood Slice Shop: Don't discount the smaller, local pizza places! Often, these hidden gems offer delicious pizza at affordable prices. Explore your surroundings and discover your new favorite!
Finding the Best Pizza for YOU in Williamsburg
Ultimately, the "best" pizza in Williamsburg is subjective. This list aims to give you a diverse range of options to help you discover your perfect slice. Consider these factors when making your choice:
- Your preferred pizza style: Do you prefer thin crust, thick crust, Neapolitan, or something else?
- Your budget: Prices range from affordable slices to gourmet pies.
- Your desired atmosphere: Are you looking for a casual quick bite or a more upscale dining experience?
With its diverse range of pizzerias, Williamsburg offers a pizza experience for everyone. So grab a slice (or two!), explore the neighborhood, and savor the deliciousness! Happy pizza hunting!
