Finding unique, affordable, and sustainable fashion options in Ithaca just got easier! This comprehensive guide showcases the twelve best consignment shops in the city, offering a diverse range of styles, prices, and inventory. Whether you're looking for vintage clothing, designer handbags, or gently used home goods, Ithaca's consignment scene has something for everyone.
Top Consignment Shops in Ithaca: A Diverse Selection
This list isn't ranked, as each shop offers a unique experience and caters to different tastes. Explore to find your perfect secondhand shopping destination!
1. The Ithaca Vintage Company
- Focus: High-quality vintage and retro clothing, accessories, and home goods.
- Vibe: Chic and curated selection, perfect for the fashion-forward shopper.
- Why it's great: Excellent selection of unique pieces you won't find anywhere else. Offers a mix of clothing from different eras and styles. Great for finding that one-of-a-kind statement piece.
2. Second Bloom
- Focus: Women's clothing and accessories, with a focus on contemporary and gently used items.
- Vibe: Bright, airy, and organized—easy to browse and find what you need.
- Why it's great: Wide selection of sizes and styles, making it easy to find something that fits. Frequently receives new inventory.
3. The Clothing Exchange
- Focus: A wide variety of clothing for men and women, plus shoes and accessories.
- Vibe: Classic consignment shop feel, with a friendly and helpful staff.
- Why it's great: Great for finding everyday wear at affordable prices. Often has sales and discounts.
4. Goodwill Ithaca
- Focus: A wide range of donated items, including clothing, household goods, electronics, and more.
- Vibe: Classic thrift store, with a constantly changing inventory.
- Why it's great: You never know what treasures you might find! Great for budget-conscious shoppers. Supports a worthy cause.
5. Buffalo Exchange
- Focus: Trendy and contemporary clothing, shoes, and accessories for men and women. They buy and sell.
- Vibe: Modern and stylish, with a focus on current fashion trends.
- Why it's great: Excellent place to find name-brand clothing at a fraction of the original price.
6. Plato's Closet
- Focus: Primarily focuses on clothing and accessories for teens and young adults. Similar to Buffalo Exchange, they buy and sell.
- Vibe: More youthful and trend-focused than some other consignment shops.
- Why it's great: Perfect for students and young professionals looking for affordable, stylish options.
7. Savers
- Focus: A large thrift store with a massive selection of clothing, home goods, and more.
- Vibe: A classic thrifting experience, with a vast inventory to explore.
- Why it's great: Best for shoppers who enjoy the thrill of the hunt and don't mind spending time searching for hidden gems.
8. Unique Finds Consignment
- Focus: A mix of clothing, accessories, home goods, and furniture.
- Vibe: A more eclectic mix of items, offering a unique and diverse shopping experience.
- Why it's great: Perfect for those who like a mix of styles and eras.
9. Reimagine Consignment
- Focus: Higher-end consignment, specializing in designer brands and luxury goods.
- Vibe: Upscale and sophisticated.
- Why it's great: Perfect for those looking for a luxurious piece without the designer price tag.
10. The Revolving Closet
- Focus: Women's clothing and accessories, with a focus on quality and style.
- Vibe: A curated selection of gently used clothing.
- Why it's great: A great place to find classic pieces that will last.
11. Collegetown Consignment
- Focus: Serving the student population, this shop offers affordable clothing and accessories.
- Vibe: A more casual atmosphere, ideal for students on a budget.
- Why it's great: Perfect for students looking for budget-friendly options.
12. Habitat for Humanity ReStore
- Focus: A wide range of gently used building materials, furniture, and home goods. Proceeds support Habitat for Humanity.
- Vibe: Practical and functional—great for home improvement projects and finding unique furniture.
- Why it's great: Supports a worthy cause and helps the environment by reusing materials.
Finding Your Perfect Secondhand Treasure in Ithaca
Ithaca's consignment scene offers a diverse range of options to suit every taste and budget. From vintage finds to designer labels, exploring these twelve shops is sure to unearth some unique treasures. Remember to check each shop's website or social media for hours, inventory updates, and any special events or promotions. Happy shopping!
