Bensonhurst, a vibrant neighborhood in Brooklyn, may be known for its Italian heritage, but it also boasts a surprisingly diverse culinary scene. Tucked away amongst the pizzerias and pasta shops are some truly fantastic Mexican restaurants, offering a taste of south-of-the-border flavors right in the heart of NYC. This guide explores the top 10, highlighting what makes each a must-visit for Mexican food lovers. Finding the best Mexican restaurant is subjective, but this list aims to cover a range of styles and price points.
Top 10 Mexican Restaurants in Bensonhurst: A Delicious Dive
This list isn't ranked in order of preference, as taste is personal! Instead, we've categorized them to help you find the perfect spot for your next Mexican food craving.
1. Taqueria El Bronco: Authentic Mexican Street Food
Taqueria El Bronco brings the authentic tastes of Mexico to Bensonhurst. Their street tacos are a highlight, filled with perfectly seasoned carne asada, al pastor, or carnitas. The tortillas are made fresh daily, contributing to the restaurant's undeniable charm. Don't miss their aguas frescas, refreshing fruit drinks that perfectly complement the spicy food. The atmosphere is casual and lively, making it ideal for a quick and satisfying meal. Their commitment to fresh ingredients is apparent in every bite.
- Price Range: $
- Specialties: Tacos, Street Food
2. La Casa Del Sol: Family-Style Mexican Feast
La Casa Del Sol offers a more upscale Mexican dining experience. They specialize in family-style platters, perfect for sharing with friends and family. Their mole poblano is a standout dish, a rich and complex sauce made with chilies, spices, and chocolate. The generous portions and warm, inviting atmosphere make it a great choice for a special occasion or a relaxed evening out.
- Price Range: $
- Specialties: Mole Poblano, Family-Style Platters
3. El Paso Cantina: Lively Atmosphere and Margarita Magic
El Paso Cantina is known for its vibrant atmosphere and creative cocktails. Their margaritas are legendary, made with fresh lime juice and top-shelf tequila. While their food menu is extensive, their fajitas are a crowd-pleaser, sizzling at the table and filled with tender marinated meats and vegetables. The loud, energetic ambiance is perfect for a fun night out with friends.
- Price Range: $
- Specialties: Margaritas, Fajitas
4. Mi Ranchito: Home-Style Cooking with a Twist
Mi Ranchito provides a taste of home-style Mexican cooking. Their menu features familiar favorites like enchiladas, burritos, and quesadillas, but with unique twists on classic recipes. The portions are generous, the prices are reasonable, and the service is friendly. This restaurant offers a comfortable and unpretentious dining experience.
- Price Range: $
- Specialties: Enchiladas, Burritos
5. El Nopal: Vegetarian and Vegan Options Galore
El Nopal is a haven for vegetarians and vegans looking for delicious Mexican food. They offer a wide variety of vegetarian and vegan options, including delicious plant-based tacos, burritos, and bowls. Their creative use of vegetables and beans ensures even meat-eaters will find something to enjoy. The restaurant's commitment to fresh, sustainable ingredients adds to its appeal.
- Price Range: $
- Specialties: Vegetarian & Vegan Mexican Dishes
6. Don Chuy's: A Taste of Southern Mexico
Don Chuy's transports you to Southern Mexico with its authentic regional dishes. They specialize in dishes from Oaxaca and Chiapas, using unique spices and ingredients. Their tlayudas, large, crispy tortillas topped with various ingredients, are a must-try. The restaurant's dedication to authentic flavors makes it a unique addition to Bensonhurst's culinary landscape.
- Price Range: $
- Specialties: Oaxacan and Chiapanecan Cuisine
7. La Tapatia: Authentic Mexican Bakery and Cafe
La Tapatia is more than just a restaurant; it's a Mexican bakery and cafe. Their pan dulce, or sweet bread, is freshly baked daily and incredibly delicious. They also offer a variety of savory items, including sopes, tamales, and tortas. This is a great place for a casual lunch or a sweet treat.
- Price Range: $
- Specialties: Pan Dulce, Sopes, Tamales
8. Maria's Taqueria: Quick Bites and Late-Night Cravings
Maria's Taqueria is perfect for quick, satisfying meals. They specialize in tacos al pastor, a popular Mexican street food. The tacos are generous in size and bursting with flavor. They’re also a great option for late-night cravings, often staying open later than many other establishments in the area.
- Price Range: $
- Specialties: Tacos al Pastor
9. La Perla: A Hidden Gem in Bensonhurst
La Perla is a hidden gem offering consistently delicious Mexican food. While it may not have the flashiest ambiance, the quality of the food is exceptional. Their chilaquiles are a breakfast staple, and their pozole is a perfect hearty meal.
- Price Range: $
- Specialties: Chilaquiles, Pozole
10. Taqueria Los Amigos: Your Neighborhood Mexican Spot
Taqueria Los Amigos is a true neighborhood favorite, offering a welcoming atmosphere and reliable Mexican food. While not overly specialized, they serve all the classics reliably and consistently. It’s a great choice for familiar favorites and friendly service.
- Price Range: $
- Specialties: Classic Mexican Dishes
This list offers a starting point for your culinary exploration of Bensonhurst's Mexican restaurants. Remember to check their hours of operation and make reservations where necessary, especially during peak times. Enjoy your culinary journey!
