DUMBO, with its cobblestone streets, stunning Manhattan Bridge views, and vibrant art scene, also boasts a surprisingly delightful dessert landscape. Forget the pizza – let's dive into the sugary goodness this Brooklyn neighborhood offers. This list compiles the top 10 desserts you absolutely must try during your DUMBO adventure. Whether you crave classic comfort or innovative artistry, DUMBO's dessert scene has something to satisfy every sweet tooth.
Top 10 Must-Try DUMBO Desserts
This carefully curated list considers quality, uniqueness, and overall experience to bring you the best of the best in DUMBO desserts. We've included a range of options to ensure there’s something for everyone, from the classic ice cream lover to the adventurous pastry aficionado.
1. Grimaldi's Pizzeria's Cannoli
While primarily known for its pizza, Grimaldi's under-appreciated cannoli shouldn't be missed. This classic Italian dessert, crispy yet yielding, is filled with a rich, creamy ricotta filling. The perfect ending to a perfect pizza experience.
Why it's great: The cannoli's delicate crisp shell contrasts beautifully with the sweet, subtly tangy ricotta filling. The simple perfection is what makes it stand out.
2. Time Out Market's Diverse Dessert Selection
Time Out Market isn't just a food hall; it's a dessert destination. Featuring a rotating selection of vendors, you can find everything from macarons and artisanal chocolates to unique ice cream flavors and decadent cakes.
Why it's great: The variety is unparalleled. You can easily sample multiple desserts in one visit, exploring a range of styles and flavors. The constantly changing menu keeps things exciting.
3. Juliana's Pizza's Classic New York Cheesecake
A sister restaurant to Grimaldi's, Juliana's offers a creamy, rich, classic New York-style cheesecake that rivals any in the city. The dense, tangy cheesecake is perfectly balanced, neither too sweet nor too heavy.
Why it's great: It's the quintessential New York cheesecake experience: a perfect balance of creaminess and tang, a satisfyingly dense texture, and a subtly sweet graham cracker crust.
4. Cecconi's Dumbo's Exquisite Italian Pastries
Cecconi's Dumbo, a sophisticated Italian restaurant, elevates the simple pastry to an art form. Their pastries are works of art, both visually stunning and intensely flavorful. Expect seasonal offerings alongside timeless classics.
Why it's great: The attention to detail is evident in every bite. Cecconi's uses high-quality ingredients and demonstrates meticulous craftsmanship. It's a luxurious dessert experience.
5. Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory's Unique Flavors
This local gem crafts inventive ice cream flavors that challenge expectations. Expect unusual combinations and unexpected bursts of flavor, often incorporating locally sourced ingredients.
Why it's great: The commitment to creativity and quality sets Brooklyn Ice Cream Factory apart. Their commitment to using fresh, local ingredients makes it a truly special treat.
6. DeStefano's Steaks & Seafood's Homemade Gelato
This upscale steakhouse features a surprisingly delightful selection of homemade gelato. The creamy, intensely flavorful gelato is the perfect counterpoint to a rich steak dinner, or an indulgence on its own.
Why it's great: The gelato's creamy texture and vibrant flavors are a testament to high-quality ingredients and traditional methods. It's a sophisticated, satisfying end to any meal.
7. Sugar Shack's Gourmet Cupcakes
Sugar Shack satisfies all your cupcake cravings. Their gourmet cupcakes boast creative flavor combinations and are decorated with flair. They are not just visually appealing but also unbelievably delicious.
Why it's great: The creative flavor combinations and beautiful presentation make Sugar Shack's cupcakes a delightful experience.
8. Jacques Torres Chocolate's Exquisite Chocolates
Jacques Torres, a celebrated chocolatier, offers a range of exquisite chocolates, from classic truffles to innovative bonbons. His shop in DUMBO is a must-visit for any chocolate lover.
Why it's great: The quality of the chocolate is exceptional. Jacques Torres' expertise and commitment to sourcing high-quality ingredients are evident in every bite.
9. Van Leeuwen Artisan Ice Cream's Vegan Options
Van Leeuwen offers a wide selection of ice cream, but its vegan options are particularly noteworthy. Creamy and delicious, they prove that plant-based ice cream can be just as satisfying as dairy-based.
Why it's great: The vegan options are surprisingly rich and creamy, proving that vegan ice cream doesn't have to compromise on taste or texture.
10. Picnic in Brooklyn Bridge Park with Your Favorite Treat
DUMBO’s proximity to Brooklyn Bridge Park makes it easy to grab your favorite dessert from one of the spots above and enjoy it while taking in the stunning Manhattan skyline views.
Why it's great: The combination of a delicious treat and a breathtaking view transforms a simple dessert into a memorable experience.
Planning Your DUMBO Dessert Crawl
To make the most of your DUMBO dessert adventure, consider planning your route in advance. Many of these spots are within walking distance of each other, making a dessert crawl a fun and rewarding experience. Don't forget to check opening hours and availability before you go, especially during peak seasons.
Remember, this list is just a starting point. DUMBO's vibrant food scene is constantly evolving, so be sure to explore and discover your own personal favorite DUMBO desserts. Happy eating!
