Lincoln Square, a vibrant neighborhood in Chicago, boasts a diverse culinary scene. But amidst the bustling restaurants and cafes, a simple yet elegant sandwich reigns supreme: the Caprese. This classic Italian combination of fresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, basil, and balsamic glaze is elevated to an art form in Lincoln Square. This guide explores the top 10 spots to savor the perfect Caprese sandwich in this charming neighborhood. Finding the best Caprese sandwich is subjective, of course, but we'll explore what makes each location special.
Top Contenders for the Best Caprese Sandwich in Lincoln Square
This list isn't ranked in any particular order; the "best" Caprese is a matter of personal preference! Each location offers a unique take on this classic.
1. A Tavola: Authentic Italian Flair
A Tavola provides a traditional Caprese experience. Their sandwich features high-quality ingredients sourced locally whenever possible. The bread is always fresh, and the balsamic glaze is perfectly balanced. Their commitment to authentic Italian techniques shines through in the simple perfection of their Caprese. Expect a slightly higher price point reflecting the quality.
- Highlight: Locally-sourced ingredients.
2. Cafe Ba-Ba-Reeba!: Tapas with a Twist
While known for its tapas, Cafe Ba-Ba-Reeba! also offers a standout Caprese sandwich. Their version might be smaller than others on this list but is packed with flavor. It’s a delightful addition to a tapas spread, demonstrating the versatility of the Caprese combination.
- Highlight: Perfect for sharing or as part of a larger meal.
3. The Village Pub: Neighborhood Gem
This beloved neighborhood pub offers a surprisingly delicious Caprese. It's a more casual take on the classic, maybe featuring a slightly more robust bread, making it a satisfying lunch or light dinner.
- Highlight: Great atmosphere and relaxed setting.
4. Mindy's HotChocolate: Sweet and Savory Fusion
Mindy's, renowned for its decadent hot chocolate, also features a creative Caprese sandwich. They might incorporate unexpected elements, perhaps a unique balsamic reduction or a different type of cheese, making it a delightful surprise.
- Highlight: Unique twist on a classic.
5. Lincoln Square Deli: Classic Deli Experience
A Lincoln Square staple, this deli offers a straightforward yet satisfying Caprese. Expect generous portions and a classic deli-style sandwich that hits the spot. This is a great option for a quick, affordable, and delicious lunch.
- Highlight: Great value and generous portions.
6. Piccolo Sogno: Elevated Italian Cuisine
Piccolo Sogno's Caprese sandwich is a more refined interpretation. They utilize high-end ingredients, making it a special occasion treat. This is a place for a truly memorable Caprese experience if you are looking for more of a fine dining feel.
- Highlight: High-end ingredients and refined preparation.
7. Lonesome Rose: Tex-Mex with a Surprise
This Tex-Mex restaurant might seem an unusual place to find a Caprese, but their version is a pleasant surprise. It demonstrates the adaptability of the Caprese's fresh ingredients, perhaps adding a southwest flair!
- Highlight: Unexpected combination of flavors.
8. The Brownstone: Upscale Casual Dining
The Brownstone's take on the Caprese leans towards the upscale-casual dining experience. Expect carefully chosen ingredients and a presentation that reflects the quality of the restaurant.
- Highlight: Stylish atmosphere and sophisticated presentation.
9. Summer House Santa Monica: California-inspired
Summer House Santa Monica brings a Californian twist to the Caprese sandwich. They might use unique bread or add interesting elements, maintaining the core Caprese flavors while delivering a novel experience.
- Highlight: California-inspired ingredients and flavors.
10. Andros Taverna: A Mediterranean Escape
Andros Taverna, a Mediterranean restaurant, offers a Caprese sandwich infused with Mediterranean herbs and spices. This adds an aromatic dimension to the classic, creating a vibrant and unique taste profile.
- Highlight: Mediterranean twist on a classic.
Finding Your Perfect Caprese Sandwich in Lincoln Square
Exploring Lincoln Square's diverse culinary scene is a journey of discovery. Whether you prefer a classic, casual, or innovative approach to the Caprese sandwich, this neighborhood has something to offer every palate. Remember to check menus and hours before visiting, as availability can vary. Bon appétit!
