Flatbush, Brooklyn, boasts a vibrant culinary scene, and among its many treasures are some truly exceptional calzones. This isn't just about folded pizza; it's about a comforting, cheesy, flavorful experience. This guide dives deep into the best 10 calzones Flatbush has to offer, exploring what makes each a standout. We'll consider factors like dough quality, filling creativity, overall taste, and the overall dining experience. Finding the perfect calzone is a journey, and we're here to guide you.
Top 10 Calzones in Flatbush: A Neighborhood's Best Kept Secrets
This list isn't ranked in order of preference – tastes are subjective! – but rather presents a diverse selection showcasing the best Flatbush has to offer in the realm of calzones. Each entry includes details to help you choose the perfect calzone for your craving.
1. L&B Spumoni Gardens
- What Makes it Special: A Flatbush institution, L&B is known for its Sicilian-style pizza, and their calzones follow suit. Expect a thick, slightly crisp crust, generous fillings, and a classic, satisfying taste.
- Signature Filling: Ricotta, mozzarella, and a hint of tomato sauce.
- Why It's a Must-Try: A taste of Flatbush history with every bite. This is a classic for a reason, offering a consistent, reliably delicious calzone experience.
2. Gino's Pizzeria
- What Makes it Special: Gino's excels in its use of fresh ingredients. Their calzones burst with flavor, showcasing the quality of their produce.
- Signature Filling: Their "Supreme" calzone is a popular choice, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and peppers.
- Why It's a Must-Try: For a calzone packed with fresh, vibrant ingredients and a focus on quality.
3. Lenny's Pizza
- What Makes it Special: Lenny's offers a unique twist on the classic calzone. They experiment with interesting flavor combinations, catering to adventurous palates.
- Signature Filling: Try their "Spicy Italian" calzone with soppressata, fresh mozzarella, and a kick of Calabrian chili peppers.
- Why It's a Must-Try: For something different and exciting, Lenny's offers a more creative approach to the calzone.
4. Sal & Carmine's Pizzeria
- What Makes it Special: A neighborhood favorite, Sal & Carmine's provides a consistently delicious calzone in a warm and friendly atmosphere.
- Signature Filling: Their classic ricotta and mozzarella calzone is perfectly executed.
- Why It's a Must-Try: For a reliable, comforting calzone experience in a welcoming setting.
5. Marco's Pizza
- What Makes it Special: Marco's often offers unique seasonal calzone specials, keeping their menu fresh and exciting.
- Signature Filling: Check their menu for seasonal offerings! They might surprise you with something innovative and delicious.
- Why It's a Must-Try: For a taste of something new and potentially unexpected.
6. Pizza Moto
- What Makes it Special: Pizza Moto offers a more modern take on the calzone, incorporating contemporary flavors and techniques.
- Signature Filling: Look for their creative combinations using artisan cheeses and interesting vegetable pairings.
- Why It's a Must-Try: For a more sophisticated and gourmet calzone experience.
7. A&A Pizzeria
- What Makes it Special: A&A is a long-standing local establishment known for its high-quality ingredients and generous portions.
- Signature Filling: Their "Meat Lovers" calzone is a popular choice for those who appreciate a meaty, flavorful filling.
- Why It's a Must-Try: For a classic, meat-lover's calzone done right.
8. Bella's Pizzeria
- What Makes it Special: Bella's often has daily specials, so there's always something new to try. Their calzones are made with care and attention to detail.
- Signature Filling: Their daily specials are worth checking out!
- Why It's a Must-Try: To experience some unexpected deliciousness.
9. Luigi's Pizzeria
- What Makes it Special: Luigi's prides itself on using only the finest ingredients and traditional methods to create authentic Italian-style calzones.
- Signature Filling: Their classic Margherita calzone, with fresh mozzarella, basil, and tomato sauce is a delicious choice.
- Why It's a Must-Try: For an authentic Italian calzone experience.
10. Joe's Pizza
- What Makes it Special: Joe's often features a wide variety of both classic and more adventurous calzone fillings. They are known for their friendly service.
- Signature Filling: Their "Veggie Supreme" is a great option for vegetarians.
- Why It's a Must-Try: For a comprehensive menu and a pleasant overall dining experience.
Finding Your Perfect Flatbush Calzone
This list is just a starting point. Flatbush's culinary scene is constantly evolving, so don't be afraid to explore and discover your own personal favorite calzone spot. Consider factors such as your preferred crust thickness, filling preferences (vegetarian, meat-lover, etc.), and the overall ambiance you're seeking. Happy calzone hunting! Remember to check restaurant websites or call ahead for current menus and hours.