Crown Heights, a vibrant neighborhood in Brooklyn, boasts a diverse culinary scene. While known for its Caribbean and Middle Eastern flavors, it also offers a surprising number of excellent seafood options, including some truly outstanding calamari. This guide dives deep into the top 10 spots serving up the best calamari in Crown Heights, considering factors like freshness, breading, frying technique, and overall dining experience. We'll explore what makes each location unique and help you find your new favorite calamari haunt.
Top 10 Calamari Spots in Crown Heights: A Culinary Journey
Finding the perfect calamari can be a quest, but in Crown Heights, the options are surprisingly plentiful. This list is based on extensive research, reviews, and personal tasting experiences, aiming to provide a comprehensive overview for calamari enthusiasts.
1. Lido: Classic Italian Calamari
Lido, a Crown Heights institution, serves up classic Italian-American fare. Their calamari is a perennial favorite, featuring perfectly tender squid rings in a light, crispy batter. The portion size is generous, and it's often served with a delicious marinara sauce. Their commitment to fresh ingredients shines through in the taste and texture.
- Why it's great: Classic preparation, fresh ingredients, generous portions.
- Price Range: $
- Atmosphere: Casual, family-friendly.
2. Island Thyme: Caribbean Calamari Twist
Island Thyme brings a unique Caribbean flair to calamari. Instead of the traditional Italian-American preparation, they often incorporate spices and jerk seasonings into the batter, creating a flavorful and exciting twist. This is a must-try for those seeking a departure from the norm.
- Why it's great: Unique Caribbean flavor profile, creative preparation.
- Price Range: $
- Atmosphere: Casual, vibrant.
3. Barboncino: Elegant Calamari Experience
If you’re looking for a more refined calamari experience, Barboncino delivers. Their calamari is prepared with an emphasis on delicate flavors and elegant presentation. The squid is expertly tenderized, and the batter is delicate and airy, allowing the taste of the squid to shine.
- Why it's great: Refined preparation, elegant presentation, sophisticated flavors.
- Price Range: $$
- Atmosphere: Upscale, romantic.
4. Frankie's 457: The Neighborhood Gem
Frankie's 457 is a neighborhood favorite known for its casual atmosphere and delicious food. Their calamari is a crowd-pleaser, offering a balance of crispy exterior and tender interior. The generous portion size and affordable price point make it a great value for money.
- Why it's great: Great value, generous portions, casual atmosphere.
- Price Range: $
- Atmosphere: Casual, neighborhood-friendly.
5. Chavela's: A Latin American Perspective
Chavela's introduces a Latin American perspective to calamari. They might offer variations with different sauces and seasonings reflecting their culinary heritage. This is an excellent option for those seeking something different and adventurous. Expect bolder, spicier flavors.
- Why it's great: Unique Latin American flavors, adventurous approach.
- Price Range: $
- Atmosphere: Lively, vibrant.
6. The Crown: Pub Fare with a Twist
The Crown, a local pub, provides a solid calamari option as part of its pub fare menu. While perhaps not the most innovative, their calamari is consistently well-prepared, crispy, and a satisfying accompaniment to a pint.
- Why it's great: Reliable quality, classic pub atmosphere.
- Price Range: $
- Atmosphere: Casual, pub-like.
7. Olde Saratoga: A Gastropub Take on Calamari
Olde Saratoga offers a gastropub take on calamari, often featuring elevated preparations and unique flavor combinations. Expect creative sauces and sides that complement the dish, offering a more sophisticated take on the classic.
- Why it's great: Creative variations, upscale pub atmosphere.
- Price Range: $$
- Atmosphere: Upscale gastropub.
8. A&J Pizza: Unexpected Calamari Delight
While primarily a pizza place, A&J Pizza often has surprisingly good calamari. Don't let the pizza focus fool you; their calamari can be a hidden gem, providing a tasty and affordable side dish or appetizer.
- Why it's great: Affordable, surprising quality, great for a casual meal.
- Price Range: $
- Atmosphere: Casual, pizza place setting.
9. Peaches: Rooftop Vibes with Calamari
Peaches, a rooftop bar, offers a unique ambiance with great city views. Their calamari is a fitting appetizer to their cocktail menu, offering a solid and enjoyable dish within a lively setting.
- Why it's great: Great atmosphere, perfect for a night out.
- Price Range: $$
- Atmosphere: Lively rooftop bar.
10. Seasoned Vegan: Plant-Based Calamari Alternative
For those seeking a vegan option, Seasoned Vegan provides a creative plant-based calamari alternative. This demonstrates the growing innovation in plant-based cuisine and offers a delicious option for vegetarian and vegan diners.
- Why it's great: Vegan-friendly, creative plant-based option.
- Price Range: $
- Atmosphere: Casual, vegan-friendly.
Finding Your Perfect Calamari in Crown Heights
This list provides a starting point for your calamari adventure in Crown Heights. Remember to check online reviews and menus for the most up-to-date information, as menus can change. Ultimately, the best calamari is the one that best suits your taste and preferences. Enjoy your culinary exploration!
