The Theater District in NYC isn't just about dazzling Broadway shows; it's a culinary hotspot. After a captivating performance, or before the curtain rises, fueling up with a delicious burger is a must. This guide unveils the ten best burger joints in the area, ensuring your theatrical experience is complete. We've considered factors like patty quality, bun texture, toppings, atmosphere, and overall value to bring you this definitive list.
Top Burger Spots Near Broadway
This section dives into the specifics of each burger joint, detailing what makes each one special and worth your time and appetite.
1. Shake Shack (Multiple Locations)
Shake Shack, a New York institution, needs no introduction. Their ShackBurger is a classic, featuring a juicy all-natural Angus beef patty, crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, creamy cheese, and their signature ShackSauce all nestled in a perfectly toasted potato roll. Their consistently high quality and convenient locations make it a reliable choice before or after a show.
Why it's great: Consistency, classic flavor, quick service.
What to order: ShackBurger, ShakeShack Fries, a Concrete (frozen custard).
2. Bill's Bar & Burger (Multiple Locations)
Bill's offers a more upscale burger experience. Their commitment to quality ingredients shines through, from their gourmet patties to their creative topping combinations. The atmosphere is lively, but not overwhelmingly loud, making it a good choice for pre- or post-theater dining.
Why it's great: Gourmet ingredients, varied menu, stylish atmosphere.
What to order: The "Bill's Classic" burger, or try one of their unique signature creations.
3. The Smith (Multiple Locations)
The Smith provides a sophisticated yet relaxed setting, perfect for a celebratory meal after a Broadway hit. Their burger is substantial, using high-quality beef and fresh toppings. The ambiance is perfect for conversation and a relaxed meal.
Why it's great: Upscale atmosphere, quality ingredients, excellent service.
What to order: The classic cheeseburger or one of their specialty burgers with unique toppings.
4. The Lambs Club (44th Street)
This more upscale establishment provides a sophisticated take on the classic American burger. Expect high quality beef, interesting toppings, and a luxurious ambiance. The Lambs Club is perfect for a special occasion or a celebratory dinner after a show.
Why it's great: High-end experience, elegant ambiance, exceptional service.
What to order: Their signature Lambs Club burger, known for its unique flavor combinations.
5. Becco (46th Street)
While primarily an Italian restaurant, Becco's burger is a hidden gem, known amongst locals for its exceptional quality. It is a more "under the radar" choice which adds to its appeal for the more discerning foodie.
Why it's great: Unexpected gem, excellent quality, often less crowded.
What to order: Their juicy and flavorful hamburger.
6. Carmine's (Multiple Locations)
Carmine's is famous for its family-style Italian-American cuisine, but they also serve a very solid burger that’s perfect if you're looking for something a bit different in a lively setting.
Why it's great: Lively atmosphere, great for groups, solid burger option.
What to order: Their classic cheeseburger – a comforting choice after a show.
7. Joe Allen (46th Street)
A classic Theater District establishment, Joe Allen offers a consistently good burger in a timeless setting. It’s a reliable choice for a pre-theater bite or a post-show meal.
Why it's great: Classic atmosphere, reliable quality, theatrical history.
What to order: The classic cheeseburger, a true Theater District staple.
8. Virgil's Real Barbecue (44th Street)
While primarily known for their barbecue, Virgil's also serves a delicious burger if you're craving something outside of traditional barbecue. It's a great option if your group has differing tastes.
Why it's great: Diverse menu, accommodates different tastes, lively atmosphere.
What to order: Their burger with a side of their signature barbecue.
9. Ellen's Stardust Diner (51st Street)
Ellen's is a unique dining experience, with singing waiters and waitresses adding to the fun. While their menu offers various items, their burger is a solid choice to fuel up before or after a show.
Why it's great: Unique and entertaining atmosphere, family-friendly.
What to order: Their classic burger to enjoy amidst the lively singing staff.
10. Junior's Restaurant (45th Street)
Known for its legendary cheesecake, Junior's also offers a surprisingly good burger. It's a classic New York diner experience with a good burger to boot.
Why it's great: Classic diner atmosphere, cheesecake, convenient location.
What to order: Their burger with a slice of their famous cheesecake for dessert.
Choosing Your Pre- or Post-Theater Burger
The best burger for you depends on your preferences and the mood you're in. Consider the atmosphere, price point, and your desired level of formality when making your choice. Remember to make reservations, especially for popular spots, particularly before a show. Enjoy your burger and the show!
