White Plains, NY boasts a surprisingly vibrant sandwich scene, offering everything from classic deli fare to gourmet creations. Whether you're craving a quick lunch or a leisurely midday meal, this guide highlights nine of the best sandwich shops in White Plains, catering to various tastes and budgets. Finding the perfect sandwich just got easier!
Top Contenders for the Best Sandwich in White Plains
This list isn't ranked in any particular order, as "best" is subjective and depends on individual preferences. However, each establishment highlighted below offers something unique and delicious. We've considered factors like ingredient quality, bread selection, creativity, customer service, and overall value.
1. The Deli on Main: A Classic Deli Experience
The Deli on Main embodies the quintessential New York City deli experience, but with a White Plains twist. Expect generous portions, high-quality meats and cheeses, and a wide array of classic sandwiches. Their pastrami on rye is legendary, drawing in locals and tourists alike. The friendly service and bustling atmosphere add to the charm.
Why it's great: Exceptional pastrami, generous portions, classic deli ambiance.
Must-try: Pastrami on rye, Reuben, Italian combo.
2. Salvatore's: Italian Specialties and More
Salvatore's elevates the humble sandwich to an art form. Their focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients, particularly their homemade breads and sauces, shines through in every bite. Their Italian-inspired sandwiches are standouts, but they also offer a selection of creative, gourmet options that cater to adventurous palates.
Why it's great: Fresh ingredients, homemade breads, creative gourmet options.
Must-try: Caprese sandwich, roasted eggplant hero, porchetta sandwich.
3. Little Drunken Chef: Asian Fusion Sandwiches
Little Drunken Chef offers a unique twist on the sandwich with their Asian-fusion creations. Expect unexpected flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients. This isn't your typical sandwich shop; it's a culinary adventure. Their banh mi is a must-try, showcasing the perfect blend of sweet, savory, and spicy flavors.
Why it's great: Unique Asian-fusion flavors, high-quality ingredients, creative combinations.
Must-try: Banh mi, Korean BBQ sandwich, Spicy Tuna Melt.
4. The Westchester Sandwich Company: A Local Favorite
The Westchester Sandwich Company is a local favorite known for its consistent quality and friendly service. They offer a wide selection of classic and creative sandwiches, using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients whenever possible. Their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction is evident in their loyal following.
Why it's great: Fresh, locally-sourced ingredients, consistent quality, friendly service.
Must-try: Turkey cranberry avocado, roasted chicken pesto, club sandwich.
5. City Limits Diner: Comfort Food Classics
City Limits Diner offers a comforting and nostalgic experience. While not solely a sandwich shop, their sandwiches are noteworthy, reflecting classic American diner fare. Think juicy burgers, melt-in-your-mouth grilled cheese, and hearty club sandwiches.
Why it's great: Classic diner fare, comforting and familiar flavors, great for a casual meal.
Must-try: BLT, grilled cheese, cheeseburger.
6. Blue Moon Mexican Cafe: Authentic Mexican Sandwiches
For a taste of Mexico, head to Blue Moon Mexican Cafe. While known for their tacos and burritos, their Mexican sandwiches are equally impressive. Expect flavorful fillings, fresh tortillas, and authentic Mexican spices. Their torta is a crowd-pleaser.
Why it's great: Authentic Mexican flavors, fresh tortillas, flavorful fillings.
Must-try: Tortas, cubanos.
7. Shake Shack: Gourmet Burgers and More
Shake Shack might be more famous for its burgers, but their chicken sandwiches are equally delicious. High-quality ingredients and a focus on simple, well-executed flavors make this a reliable choice for a quick and satisfying meal.
Why it's great: High-quality ingredients, simple and satisfying, quick service.
Must-try: ShackBurger, Chicken Shack.
8. PJ's Bar & Grill: Casual and Relaxed Atmosphere
PJ's Bar & Grill offers a relaxed atmosphere where you can enjoy a variety of sandwiches along with other pub fare. Their selection might not be as extensive as some other spots, but the quality of the ingredients and the friendly service make it a worthwhile stop.
Why it's great: Relaxed atmosphere, good for a casual meal, friendly service.
Must-try: Philly cheesesteak, reuben.
9. Starbucks: A Quick and Convenient Option
While not a dedicated sandwich shop, Starbucks provides a convenient option for a quick and easy sandwich. Their selection might be limited, but their offerings are generally reliable and consistent, making them a good choice when you're short on time.
Why it's great: Convenient location, quick service, reliable quality.
Must-try: Turkey bacon avocado, egg and cheese breakfast sandwich.
Finding Your Perfect White Plains Sandwich
White Plains offers a diverse range of sandwich options to suit every palate and budget. From classic delis to gourmet creations and quick-service options, there's a perfect sandwich waiting to be discovered. Happy eating!
