New York City, a culinary melting pot, offers a surprising abundance of excellent fish and chips options, far beyond what you might expect in a metropolis known for its diverse cuisines. Forget the soggy disappointment; these 23 spots deliver crispy, flaky fish with perfectly seasoned chips, each offering a unique twist on this classic dish. Whether you crave traditional fare or a modern interpretation, this guide will help you navigate the city's best fish and chips experiences.
Discovering the Best Fish and Chips in NYC: A Neighborhood Guide
This list is organized geographically to help you easily find the perfect fish and chips near you, no matter where you are in the city. Each entry includes a brief description, highlighting what makes it special.
Manhattan
-
The Mermaid Inn (multiple locations): A classic seafood restaurant with multiple locations throughout Manhattan, offering consistently good fish and chips with a refined touch. Their beer batter is a standout.
-
John's of Bleecker Street: This iconic New York institution serves up generous portions of classic fish and chips, perfect for a casual meal.
-
The Smith (multiple locations): A popular gastropub chain with multiple Manhattan locations, The Smith provides a reliable and enjoyable fish and chips option in a lively atmosphere.
-
Shake Shack (multiple locations): While known for burgers, Shake Shack's fish and chips are surprisingly good, offering a quick and tasty option for a casual meal.
-
The Clocktower: This sophisticated restaurant offers an elevated take on fish and chips, utilizing high-quality ingredients and refined techniques.
Brooklyn
-
Olde Brooklyn Brewery: Enjoy your fish and chips with a craft beer at this popular brewery. They focus on locally sourced ingredients.
-
The River Cafe: While pricier, this stunning restaurant overlooking the Manhattan skyline offers a truly memorable fish and chips experience with breathtaking views.
-
Cecilia: Located in Williamsburg, Cecilia provides a modern twist on the classic dish, incorporating seasonal ingredients and unique flavor profiles.
-
Brighton Bar: A British-style pub in Williamsburg, this is your spot for a truly authentic fish and chips experience in a cozy atmosphere.
-
Threes Brewing: Another Brooklyn brewery with a solid fish and chips offering, perfect for a relaxed afternoon or evening.
Queens
-
The Malt House: Located in Long Island City, this gastropub serves excellent fish and chips in a warm, inviting environment.
-
Rockaway Clam Bar: If you're heading to Rockaway Beach, stop by this iconic seafood spot for fresh, expertly prepared fish and chips with an ocean view.
Other Boroughs
-
Bronx Alehouse: This Bronx pub offers a hearty and satisfying fish and chips experience, perfect for a casual night out.
-
The White Horse Tavern (Staten Island): A historic tavern with a surprisingly good fish and chips selection, providing a taste of history along with your meal.
-
The Grey Lady: A hidden gem in Staten Island, this spot serves up fresh, delicious fish and chips in a relaxed setting.
Beyond the Basics: Finding Your Perfect Fish and Chips
The beauty of fish and chips lies in its versatility. Many establishments offer variations on the classic, adding unique touches to cater to different tastes. Consider these factors when choosing your next fish and chips experience:
- Type of Fish: Cod, haddock, and pollock are common choices. Some restaurants offer more exotic options, like halibut or mahi-mahi.
- Batter Type: Traditional beer batter is a classic, but some restaurants use tempura batter or other variations.
- Chip Style: Thick-cut, skinny fries, or even sweet potato fries are all possibilities.
- Sauces: Tartar sauce, malt vinegar, and aioli are common accompaniments.
Tips for Choosing the Best Fish and Chips in NYC
- Read Reviews: Check online reviews before heading out to get a sense of the quality and consistency of the fish and chips.
- Consider the Atmosphere: Do you want a casual pub experience or a fine-dining setting?
- Check the Menu: Look for restaurants that highlight fresh, high-quality ingredients.
- Don't Be Afraid to Venture Off the Beaten Path: Some of the best hidden gems are in less-obvious locations.
Conclusion: Your Fish and Chips Adventure Awaits!
New York City offers a wealth of options for fish and chips enthusiasts. This guide serves as a starting point for your culinary journey. With so many exceptional choices, your only challenge will be deciding where to go first! So grab your friends, family, or a loved one and embark on a delicious fish and chips adventure across the five boroughs. Enjoy!
