Staten Island, New York City's often-overlooked borough, boasts a surprisingly vibrant culinary scene, especially when it comes to seafood. With its proximity to the water, it's no surprise that fresh, delicious seafood is a staple. This guide dives into 14 of the best seafood restaurants Staten Island has to offer, catering to various tastes and budgets. Whether you're craving a casual clam bake or a sophisticated seafood dinner, this list has something for everyone. This guide will help you navigate the Staten Island seafood scene and find your new favorite spot.
Top Choices for the Best Seafood on Staten Island
This section highlights some of our top picks, categorized for easier navigation. Finding the perfect seafood restaurant depends on your preferences.
Upscale Seafood Experiences
-
**Lido: ** Lido offers a refined dining experience with stunning waterfront views. Their menu features expertly prepared seafood dishes using high-quality, locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Expect impeccable service and an elegant ambiance. Their signature lobster ravioli is a must-try.
-
The Water's Edge: This upscale restaurant delivers a sophisticated atmosphere paired with innovative seafood creations. They're known for their seasonal menus, ensuring the freshest ingredients are always featured. Expect creative presentations and an extensive wine list. Their grilled octopus is a popular choice.
Mid-Range Seafood Delights
-
Angelina's Ristorante: This popular spot provides a balance of quality and price. They offer a wide variety of seafood dishes, from classic preparations to more modern interpretations. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it perfect for a family dinner or a romantic evening out. Try their linguine with clams.
-
Enoteca Maria: While known for its rotating chef program featuring Italian grandmothers, Enoteca Maria consistently features incredible seafood dishes within their ever-changing menu. The fresh pasta and unique family recipes make this a hidden gem.
-
Flagship Restaurant: This well-established restaurant consistently delivers delicious seafood in a casual yet elegant setting. Their extensive menu offers a variety of options to please every palate. They're well-known for their generous portions and fresh fish selections.
Casual Seafood Joints
-
Joe's Crab Shack: (While a chain, their Staten Island location is worth mentioning for its lively atmosphere and casual dining experience.) Enjoy classic crab dishes and other seafood favorites in a relaxed, family-friendly setting. Don't miss their famous crab legs.
-
The Clam Bar: A Staten Island institution, The Clam Bar is perfect for a casual seafood meal. They offer fresh oysters, clams, and other shellfish, prepared simply yet deliciously. This is your spot for a no-frills, classic seafood experience.
-
South Fin Grill: Another more casual, reliable option for excellent seafood. They are well-known for their fish and chips and seafood platters, offering solid quality at a fair price.
Hidden Gems & Unique Experiences
-
Vincent's Clam Bar: A classic, family-owned clam bar, Vincent's offers a taste of old Staten Island. Their simple menu focuses on fresh, high-quality seafood cooked to perfection.
-
Portobello: While not strictly a seafood restaurant, Portobello offers an impressive selection of seafood pasta dishes and other seafood entrees within their Italian menu. The quality of the ingredients shines through.
-
Ristorante il Giardino: Similar to Portobello, Il Giardino offers exquisite Italian cuisine with a focus on using fresh, high-quality seafood in many of their dishes.
Seafood Markets with Prepared Foods
-
Local Seafood Markets: Many excellent seafood markets on Staten Island offer prepared food options, often including fresh lobster rolls, clam chowder, and other seafood delights. Check your local listings for nearby options. This is a great way to get extremely fresh seafood prepared quickly.
-
Cetta's Seafood: A well-regarded seafood market that also provides prepared dishes and sides, allowing you to grab some fresh seafood to go and enjoy.
-
Other Markets: Explore your neighborhood! Many smaller, family-owned seafood markets are scattered throughout Staten Island and offer their own unique preparations. Ask around and discover your local gem.
Choosing the Right Staten Island Seafood Restaurant for You
The best seafood restaurant on Staten Island for you will depend on several factors:
- Budget: Prices vary significantly between upscale establishments and casual eateries.
- Ambiance: Do you prefer a formal setting or a relaxed atmosphere?
- Cuisine Style: Are you looking for traditional seafood dishes or more innovative creations?
- Location: Consider the convenience of the restaurant's location.
Remember to check restaurant websites or call ahead for hours, menus, and reservations, especially on weekends or during peak season.
Enjoy your Staten Island seafood adventure!
