Rochester, NY boasts a vibrant culinary scene, and within that, a thriving sandwich subculture. From classic grinders to inventive gourmet creations, the city offers a diverse range of sandwich experiences. This guide highlights fourteen of the best sandwich shops in Rochester, catering to various tastes and preferences. We’ve considered factors like ingredient quality, bread selection, creativity, and overall customer experience to compile this list. This isn't just a list; it's your guide to Rochester's tastiest sandwiches.
Rochester's Top Sandwich Spots: A Culinary Journey
This list showcases the diversity of Rochester's sandwich scene, from classic delis to modern gourmet establishments. Whether you crave a simple ham and swiss or an innovative creation, Rochester has something to satisfy your sandwich cravings.
Classic Deli Delights:
-
Nick Tahou Hots: No Rochester sandwich list is complete without mentioning Nick Tahou Hots. This iconic establishment is famous for its garbage plates, but their sandwiches are equally legendary. The char-grilled meats are piled high on crusty rolls, creating a flavor explosion. Pro-tip: try the "garbage plate" sandwich, a unique blend of their signature flavors.
-
DiBella's Subs: A Rochester staple, DiBella's is known for its generous portions and fresh ingredients. Their extensive menu offers a vast selection of classic Italian subs, along with creative specials. The Italian sub is a must-try, with its perfect balance of meats, cheeses, and vegetables. Their commitment to quality ingredients shines through in every bite.
-
The Original Italian Deli: A Rochester institution, this deli serves classic Italian sandwiches, using high quality meats and cheeses. Their homemade bread is a highlight, enhancing the overall sandwich experience. Expect large portions and a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
Gourmet Sandwich Havens:
-
Salinger's: This upscale eatery focuses on high-quality, locally-sourced ingredients. Their unique sandwich creations are both innovative and delicious. Their menu changes seasonally, ensuring freshness and variety. Expect creative combinations and a sophisticated presentation.
-
Good Luck: This trendy spot offers a curated selection of gourmet sandwiches made with unique ingredient combinations and artisan breads. Their vegetarian and vegan options are especially noteworthy, showcasing the versatility of the sandwich format.
-
The Cub Room: Known for its upscale bar and ambiance, The Cub Room also boasts a noteworthy sandwich menu. Expect creative flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients. The sandwiches are perfect for a sophisticated lunch or a pre-dinner snack.
Diverse and Delicious:
-
Marge's Lakeside Inn: Nestled by the lake, this spot offers casual dining with a great view, and importantly, fantastic sandwiches! Their menu features options ranging from classic club sandwiches to more creative selections. The location alone adds to the appeal.
-
Park Avenue Pub: This popular pub offers a comprehensive sandwich menu featuring both classic and creative options. The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, making it perfect for a casual meal with friends.
-
Three Heads Brewing: While known for its craft beers, Three Heads Brewing also offers a surprisingly delicious sandwich menu. The brewery setting provides a lively backdrop for enjoying your meal. This offers a great option for those looking to combine craft beer with a satisfying sandwich.
Hidden Gems and Unique Finds:
-
Roc City Subs: This local favorite offers a solid selection of sandwiches made with fresh ingredients and locally-sourced options when possible. Their commitment to the community is reflected in their high-quality offerings and friendly service.
-
Wegmans (prepared foods section): Yes, even Wegmans deserves a mention! While not a dedicated sandwich shop, their prepared foods section often has surprisingly delicious and high-quality sandwiches, perfect for a quick and affordable option.
-
Little Lebowski Urban Winery: Beyond the wine, they offer sandwiches, which is a nice perk to their unique and enjoyable atmosphere.
Sweet Treats & More:
-
Donut Crazy: While primarily known for donuts, they do offer some sandwiches that pair perfectly with their sweet treats, making it an interesting addition to the Rochester sandwich scene.
-
Flower City Pickle Co.: While not strictly a sandwich shop, they feature sandwiches using their famous pickles, creating a unique and delicious experience. It's a niche option but worth checking out for pickle lovers.
Finding Your Perfect Rochester Sandwich
This list provides a diverse starting point for your Rochester sandwich adventure. Remember to explore beyond these fourteen, as the city is full of culinary surprises. Consider factors like your preferred style (classic deli, gourmet, or something unique), desired ingredients, and desired atmosphere when making your selection. Happy eating!
