Soho, New York City, pulsates with energy, a vibrant blend of art, fashion, and of course, incredible food. Within this iconic neighborhood, Italian restaurants shine, offering a diverse range of culinary experiences, from classic trattorias to modern, innovative eateries. This guide explores 14 of the best, ensuring your next Soho dining adventure is truly unforgettable. We'll delve into each restaurant's unique ambiance, signature dishes, and what makes them stand out in the competitive Soho food scene.
Classic Italian Charm: Traditional Trattorias
These establishments capture the essence of Italian dining, transporting you to charming trattorias in Italy's vibrant cities.
1. Carbone
- Ambiance: Old-school glamour, dimly lit, and sophisticated. Think classic red booths and impeccable service.
- Signature Dishes: Their spicy rigatoni vodka is legendary, and their lobster Fra Diavolo is a must-try for seafood lovers.
- Why it's great: Carbone flawlessly executes classic Italian-American dishes with a touch of modern flair. It's a truly special occasion destination.
2. Balthazar
- Ambiance: Grand and bustling, Balthazar captures the energy of a Parisian brasserie with an Italian twist.
- Signature Dishes: Their pasta dishes, particularly the tagliatelle with bolognese, are renowned for their rich flavors and generous portions. The oysters are also a popular choice.
- Why it's great: Balthazar provides a vibrant and exciting atmosphere, perfect for a lively dinner with friends or a romantic date.
3. Via Carota
- Ambiance: Rustic and charming, Via Carota feels like a hidden gem tucked away on a quiet Italian street.
- Signature Dishes: Their simple, yet flawlessly executed pasta dishes are the stars of the show. The seasonal vegetables are also a highlight.
- Why it's great: Via Carota offers a relaxed and intimate setting, ideal for a casual yet memorable meal.
Modern Italian Flair: Innovative Approaches to Classics
These restaurants offer a fresh take on traditional Italian cuisine, incorporating modern techniques and ingredients.
4. Lilia
- Ambiance: Stylish and modern, Lilia boasts a sleek design and a buzzing atmosphere.
- Signature Dishes: Their handmade pasta is exceptional, with constantly rotating seasonal specials. The grilled octopus is a popular appetizer.
- Why it's great: Lilia masterfully blends traditional Italian techniques with contemporary culinary sensibilities.
5. Cecconi's Dumbo
- Ambiance: Sophisticated and chic, Cecconi's exudes an air of elegance and refinement.
- Signature Dishes: Their seafood dishes are a particular highlight, showcasing fresh, high-quality ingredients.
- Why it's great: Cecconi's provides a luxurious dining experience, perfect for a special occasion or an indulgent night out.
6. Don Angie
- Ambiance: Intimate and cozy, Don Angie offers a warm and inviting atmosphere.
- Signature Dishes: Their pasta dishes, such as the cacio e pepe and the mafaldine with sausage ragu, are consistently praised.
- Why it's great: Don Angie serves up exceptional pasta in a comfortable and unpretentious setting.
Hidden Gems and Unique Experiences
These restaurants offer unique dining experiences that set them apart from the crowd.
7. Bar Pitti
- Ambiance: A classic Italian bar with a lively atmosphere.
- Signature Dishes: Their extensive wine list and small plates are perfect for sharing.
- Why it's great: Bar Pitti is a great place to experience the vibrant Soho nightlife scene.
8. Rubirosa
- Ambiance: Nostalgic and classic, Rubirosa offers a taste of old-school New York pizza.
- Signature Dishes: Their thin-crust pizzas are famous for their delicious, simple ingredients.
- Why it's great: Rubirosa is a perfect place for a casual, satisfying meal that's a New York classic.
9. Prince Street Pizza
- Ambiance: Casual and counter-service, Prince Street Pizza is a Soho institution.
- Signature Dishes: Their large, foldable slices are legendary amongst New Yorkers and tourists alike.
- Why it's great: A truly authentic, iconic New York pizza experience.
Beyond the Traditional: Exploring Diverse Italian Flavors
These restaurants take you beyond the classic Italian trattoria, offering unique twists and regional specialties.
10. Parm
- Ambiance: Casual and fun, Parm is a great option for a casual Italian-American meal.
- Signature Dishes: Their hero sandwiches and pasta dishes are consistently delicious.
- Why it's great: Parm provides a fun, energetic atmosphere for a great night out.
11. DeStefano's Steak House
- Ambiance: A classic steakhouse with an Italian flair.
- Signature Dishes: Their perfectly cooked steaks and delicious sides.
- Why it's great: A high-end dining experience that combines Italian hospitality with classic steakhouse fare.
12. Blossom du Jour
- Ambiance: A flower shop and cafe combo that is quite unique to Soho.
- Signature Dishes: Their panini, salads, and espresso are fresh and inviting.
- Why it's great: A charming and unique combination for a lunch or afternoon pick-me-up.
Sweet Endings: Pastry Perfection
No Italian culinary journey is complete without indulging in exquisite desserts. These spots offer delightful treats to round off your meal.
13. Ladurée Soho
- Ambiance: Elegant and refined, Ladurée offers a luxurious experience.
- Signature Dishes: Their macarons are world-renowned.
- Why it's great: Ladurée elevates the dessert experience with their beautiful macarons and other treats.
14. Dominique Ansel Bakery
- Ambiance: A bakery with a queue you can always count on!
- Signature Dishes: The Cronut is world famous and always worth the wait.
- Why it's great: A unique pastry experience that's a modern twist on the classic.
This list offers a diverse selection of the best Italian restaurants Soho has to offer, showcasing the neighborhood's vibrant and ever-evolving culinary scene. Whether you crave classic trattoria charm, modern innovation, or a unique dining experience, you're sure to find your perfect Italian escape in Soho. Remember to check menus and make reservations where necessary, especially during peak hours. Enjoy your culinary journey!
