New York City, a culinary melting pot, offers a surprising array of options for pesto lovers beyond the jarred variety. This vibrant sauce, traditionally made with basil, pine nuts, Parmesan cheese, garlic, and olive oil, has found its way into countless restaurants and cafes across the five boroughs. This guide explores 14 of the best places to savor fresh pesto in NYC, highlighting the unique interpretations and exceptional quality each establishment offers. Whether you're a pesto purist or eager to explore inventive twists, this list caters to every palate.
Discovering the Best Pesto Experiences in NYC
Finding the perfect pesto can be an adventure. Some places pride themselves on classic preparations, while others showcase innovative variations incorporating seasonal ingredients or different herbs. This list considers both classic and modern approaches, ensuring diverse choices for every pesto enthusiast.
Classic Pesto Perfection
These restaurants prioritize traditional pesto recipes, emphasizing high-quality ingredients and authentic techniques.
-
Lilia: This renowned Brooklyn restaurant serves a truly exceptional pesto, often featuring alongside their remarkable pasta dishes. The freshness of the basil is undeniable, and the balance of flavors is exquisite. Expect a richer, more nuanced pesto experience than your average Italian restaurant.
-
Via Carota: Located in the West Village, Via Carota is known for its charming atmosphere and consistently delicious Italian food. Their pesto is a highlight, simple yet perfectly executed, showcasing the quality of their ingredients.
-
Misi: This acclaimed pasta-focused restaurant in Williamsburg emphasizes handmade pasta and exceptional sauces. Their pesto is no exception, using fresh, high-quality ingredients to create a truly memorable dish.
-
Scarpetta: A staple in the New York City fine-dining scene, Scarpetta consistently delivers high-quality Italian cuisine. Their pesto, while often incorporated into other dishes, is a testament to their commitment to fresh, simple ingredients and authentic Italian flavors.
Beyond the Basics: Innovative Pesto Creations
Many establishments in NYC offer exciting variations on the classic pesto theme, incorporating unique ingredients and flavors.
-
Osteria Morini: This stylish SoHo restaurant offers a consistently excellent pesto, often incorporated into their pasta dishes. Their approach often features subtle variations, showcasing seasonal ingredients or interesting pairings.
-
La Pecora Bianca: Located in the West Village, La Pecora Bianca is a charming restaurant known for its rustic Italian dishes. Their pesto, often served as a component within broader dishes, reflects a commitment to fresh, locally-sourced ingredients.
-
Estela: This celebrated Lower East Side restaurant showcases a modern take on Italian cuisine, often highlighting fresh, seasonal ingredients. Their pesto, often included in creatively designed plates, often showcases unexpected flavor combinations.
-
Lilia (again, but for a different pesto variation): While Lilia excels with its classic pesto, they also occasionally offer unique pesto variations on their seasonal menus. Keep an eye out for their creative interpretations, which often involve different herbs or nut variations.
Hidden Gems and Unexpected Finds
These places offer surprisingly delicious pesto, often as a side or part of a larger dish. Don't overlook them!
-
Pasta By Hudson: This casual pasta spot in Tribeca is a hidden gem, delivering high-quality, simple pasta dishes with exceptional sauces, including a flavorful pesto.
-
Guss's Pickles: While not solely a pasta establishment, Guss's Pickles, known for its eclectic menu, offers a highly regarded pesto option, often integrated into a creative dish.
-
Don Angie: This West Village restaurant is known for its bold flavors and shared plates. Their occasional pesto offering is usually innovative, showcasing exciting ingredient combinations.
Beyond the Restaurant Scene: Finding Pesto in NYC
Beyond restaurants, you can find exceptional pesto in other locations:
-
Greenmarkets: Many New York City greenmarkets offer artisanal pesto made by local producers, offering a chance to support local farmers and enjoy unique flavor profiles. The seasonal availability varies, so check regularly.
-
Specialty Food Shops: Several specialty food shops around the city offer high-quality, small-batch pesto, often crafted with unusual herbs or nuts. Explore different shops to discover hidden gems.
-
Make Your Own: For the truly adventurous, consider making your own pesto at home! NYC has excellent access to fresh produce, making homemade pesto a rewarding experience.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Your Pesto
- Ingredient Quality: Look for restaurants that emphasize fresh, high-quality ingredients, particularly basil, which is the heart of any good pesto.
- Balance of Flavors: The ideal pesto should have a harmonious balance of basil, garlic, pine nuts, Parmesan cheese, and olive oil. Avoid overly pungent or bitter flavors.
- Texture: The pesto should have a smooth yet slightly chunky texture, showcasing the freshness of the ingredients.
- Creativity (Optional): While a classic pesto is always welcome, don't shy away from trying inventive variations using different herbs or nuts.
This guide showcases the diverse landscape of pesto in NYC. Explore these establishments and discover your own personal favorite pesto experiences! Happy eating!
