Utica, New York, might not be the first place that springs to mind when you think of fresh seafood. Known more for its Italian-American cuisine, Utica surprisingly boasts a number of excellent restaurants offering delicious seafood dishes. This guide dives into 11 of the best, showcasing their specialties and what makes them stand out. Whether you crave classic fish and chips or something more adventurous, this list caters to every seafood palate.
Utica's Hidden Seafood Gems: A Deep Dive into 11 Top Choices
Finding great seafood in a landlocked city like Utica requires a bit of exploration, but the reward is well worth the effort. These restaurants have proven their commitment to quality ingredients and satisfying their customers' seafood cravings.
1. The Bluefin Bistro (Upscale Dining Experience)
The Bluefin Bistro prides itself on sourcing the freshest seafood available, often flying it in daily. Their menu changes seasonally to reflect the best catches. Expect impeccable service, elegant ambiance, and dishes prepared with artistry. They're known for their pan-seared scallops and lobster risotto.
Specialties: Pan-seared scallops, lobster risotto, grilled swordfish. Price Range: $$
2. Captain's Catch (Casual Seafood Joint)
A Utica institution, Captain's Catch offers a relaxed atmosphere and consistently delicious seafood at affordable prices. They're a great option for families and those looking for a casual meal. Their fish and chips are legendary, but don't miss their clam chowder.
Specialties: Fish and chips, clam chowder, seafood platter. Price Range: $
3. The Waterfront Grill (Lakefront Views and Fresh Catches)
While not directly on a waterfront, The Waterfront Grill evokes a coastal ambiance. They emphasize locally sourced ingredients whenever possible, including fresh catches from nearby lakes and rivers whenever in season. The stunning interior and friendly service add to the experience.
Specialties: Grilled salmon, lake trout, shrimp scampi. Price Range: $$
4. The Rusty Anchor (Seafood with a Twist)
The Rusty Anchor offers a unique take on seafood, blending traditional preparations with innovative culinary techniques. They often incorporate locally foraged ingredients into their dishes, creating a truly distinctive dining experience. Their menu changes frequently, so there’s always something new to try.
Specialties: Spicy tuna tartar, pan-seared cod with seasonal vegetables, lobster mac and cheese. Price Range: $$
5. Pier 13 Seafood Shack (Casual and Affordable)
For a quick and tasty seafood meal, Pier 13 Seafood Shack is a great choice. Their menu focuses on classic seafood dishes, prepared simply and expertly. Expect generous portions and friendly service. A perfect spot for a casual lunch or dinner.
Specialties: Fish tacos, lobster rolls, shrimp po'boys. Price Range: $-$$
6. The Crab Shack (Crab Specialties)
As the name suggests, The Crab Shack specializes in crab dishes, offering everything from steamed crabs to crab cakes and crab bisque. They source their crab from reputable suppliers, ensuring freshness and quality. A great option for crab lovers!
Specialties: Steamed crabs, crab cakes, crab bisque. Price Range: $$
7. Seafood Galore (Extensive Seafood Menu)
Seafood Galore lives up to its name, offering a wide array of seafood dishes to satisfy any craving. From grilled fish to fried seafood platters, they have something for everyone. Their extensive menu makes it an excellent option for large groups.
Specialties: Grilled salmon, fried calamari, seafood pasta dishes. Price Range: $-$$
8. The Oyster Bar (Fresh Oysters and More)
The Oyster Bar is a haven for oyster enthusiasts, offering a selection of fresh oysters from different regions. But they also serve a variety of other seafood dishes, making it a versatile option for seafood lovers. Ask about their daily oyster specials!
Specialties: Fresh oysters, oyster shooters, clam bake. Price Range: $$
9. The Fish Market Restaurant (From Market to Plate)
The Fish Market Restaurant offers a unique dining experience, as it operates directly connected to a fish market. You can select your own fish from the market and have it prepared to your liking. Freshness is guaranteed!
Specialties: Grilled fish, fish tacos, lobster tail. Price Range: $$
10. Luigi's Italian Seafood (A Fusion Approach)
Luigi's Italian Seafood cleverly combines Italian culinary traditions with fresh seafood ingredients, creating a unique fusion dining experience. Their dishes are beautifully plated and offer an intriguing mix of flavors.
Specialties: Seafood risotto, linguine with clams, grilled shrimp with pesto. Price Range: $$
11. The Lighthouse Inn (Upscale Coastal Ambiance)
The Lighthouse Inn offers an elegant dining experience with a coastal ambiance, creating a sophisticated escape. They focus on high-quality seafood dishes, with an emphasis on presentation and service. A perfect spot for a special occasion.
Specialties: Seared tuna, pan-seared halibut, lobster thermidor. Price Range: $$
Finding Your Perfect Utica Seafood Experience
This list provides a diverse range of options for enjoying seafood in Utica, NY. From casual eateries to upscale restaurants, there's a perfect spot to satisfy your seafood cravings. Remember to check restaurant websites for menus, hours, and reservations before your visit. Enjoy your delicious Utica seafood adventure!
